The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Basketball (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/)
-   -   Video request: Duke v SFA final play of OT (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/104822-video-request-duke-v-sfa-final-play-ot.html)

Nevadaref Wed Nov 27, 2019 12:35am

Video request: Duke v SFA final play of OT
 
Could we please get the final ten seconds of the Duke v SFA OT posted for review?

I just saw the highlight on SportsCenter and have a couple of questions about the sequence.

JRutledge Wed Nov 27, 2019 01:33am

What are you looking for?

Peace

Nevadaref Wed Nov 27, 2019 01:47am

Start with the Duke player dribbling into the FT lane and losing the ball.

At that point my questions arise:
1. Foul or good hustle by the SFA player diving onto the floor around the Duke player’s legs?
2. Travel by the SFA player on the floor who obtained possession while prone and then turned to his back and sat up prior to passing? Do the NFHS and NCAA traveling interps differ on this action?
3. Foul by the Duke player in the backcourt as the SFA player with the ball starts to break for the other end?
4. Possible GT or BI on the winning lay-up? (I believe that the Duke player missed the ball.)

nolanjj68 Wed Nov 27, 2019 05:15am

Illegal dribble
 
Vide is here: https://streamable.com/wzjbf

On the transition and game winning basket it looked to me like the SFA player had control as he split the defenders while dribbling, made it through, then picked the ball up with both hands again, then dribbled, which is an illegal or double dribble.

I'm interested in other opinions on this.

eagle_12 Wed Nov 27, 2019 06:35am

Quote:

Originally Posted by nolanjj68 (Post 1035530)
Vide is here: https://streamable.com/wzjbf

On the transition and game winning basket it looked to me like the SFA player had control as he split the defenders while dribbling, made it through, then picked the ball up with both hands again, then dribbled, which is an illegal or double dribble.

I'm interested in other opinions on this.

Not a hoops ref, I work baseball, but my first viewing of the play last night gave me a “that doesn’t look quite right” feeling. Couple replays and I still had it.

Don’t know applications and interpretations but it doesn’t look right to me.

Nevadaref Wed Nov 27, 2019 07:14am

Quote:

Originally Posted by nolanjj68 (Post 1035530)
Vide is here: https://streamable.com/wzjbf

On the transition and game winning basket it looked to me like the SFA player had control as he split the defenders while dribbling, made it through, then picked the ball up with both hands again, then dribbled, which is an illegal or double dribble.

I'm interested in other opinions on this.

This action happens with my point #3. There may have been a foul which caused the awkward (perhaps illegal) dribble. I couldn’t tell on ESPN because there is a score ticker across the bottom of the screen which blocks some of my view.

nolanjj68 Wed Nov 27, 2019 07:18am

Yup
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Nevadaref (Post 1035532)
This action happens with my point #3. There may have been a foul which caused the awkward (perhaps illegal) dribble. I couldn’t tell on ESPN because there is a score ticker across the bottom of the screen which blocks some of my view.

Yes I agree the angle is not great. Perhaps the ball also touched a defender. Perhaps he was fouled. It would be nice to get an angle from the end line.

SC Official Wed Nov 27, 2019 08:51am

Not even close to an illegal dribble on the fastbreak.

A dribble is a controlled action. The first bounce before both hands touch the ball is not controlled.

Raymond Wed Nov 27, 2019 09:13am

I have a travel by the player on the floor who rolls completely over after gaining possession. I do not have an illegal dribble as the player muffed the passed, then hit the ball, then gained possession, then started his dribble.

nolanjj68 Wed Nov 27, 2019 10:58am

Quote:

Originally Posted by SC Official (Post 1035534)
Not even close to an illegal dribble on the fastbreak.

A dribble is a controlled action. The first bounce before both hands touch the ball is not controlled.

Of course it's close. That's why it's being debated. Sheesh this place.

nolanjj68 Wed Nov 27, 2019 11:00am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Raymond (Post 1035538)
I have a travel by the player on the floor who rolls completely over after gaining possession. I do not have an illegal dribble as the player muffed the passed, then hit the ball, then gained possession, then started his dribble.

Good catch I missed that. A clear travel on the roll over.

dabard Wed Nov 27, 2019 12:08pm

Travel or jump-stop?
 
Travel by Stanley on the 3-pointer towards the end of regulation?

https://www.cbssports.com/college-ba...-against-duke/

Not the best page for the review, but the video at the top of the story shows the key plays. Go to the 28 second mark. Player receives ball with both feet on the court. Shifts both feet to take the shot. There's a slow motion replay afterwards.

Does that count as a jump stop?

bob jenkins Wed Nov 27, 2019 12:26pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by dabard (Post 1035545)
Player receives ball with both feet on the court. Shifts both feet to take the shot.
Does that count as a jump stop?

I didn't watch the video, but two-to-two can never qualify as a jump stop.

nolanjj68 Wed Nov 27, 2019 01:04pm

Another travel
 
I watched it and he caught the ball, jumped both feet off the ground while rotating for the shot, landed, then shot. A clear travel right in front of the official.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:29pm.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1