Overturned Charge - Warriors vs Cavs

[SC Official]

Originally Posted by thedewed

but they didn't stay within the rules, because it was crystal clear to Maurer, or should have been unless he is blind, that LJ was nowhere near the RA. That is the only way they can go to the monitor. The prereq was not there. that's the problem, a biggie. They went outside the clear rules.

This is so wrong that it doesn't even warrant a response. And if you're going to criticize an official, try spelling his name right.

[thedewed]

Originally Posted by SC Official

This is so wrong that it doesn't even warrant a response. And if you're going to criticize an official, try spelling his name right.

what are you talking about? Kenny whatever his name is, the only way he can go to the monitor is if he has doubt on the RA in that situation. they abused, i.e. didn't follow, the rule. there is no question about that.

another glaring error was with 6 to go, LJ got stripped by getting hit on the forearm with the ball high. when the ball doesn't go the same direction as the force of the reach, you can be confident it was on the arm, not the ball. similar to when a dribbler misses the dribble completely in some traffic. his arm got hit, the ball didn't.

I think it was a charge, a player is allowed to brace for the contact as he is steamrolled. LJ was there in plenty of time, with both feet down and no longer moving forward, and if he then twists a hair in bracing for the contact, or the trailing foot catches up to the body a bit, particularly when moving AWAY from the drive, not towards, that's a charge. could swing the series. it was close enough that it is excusable to call a block rather than a charge, but given the rule on when you can go to the monitor, and LJ set up at least a foot outside, that is inexcusable. The NBA guys are clearly the best in the world , but that was botched.

[TopicalTropical]

Sorry, I did not see the game so I'm not sure about this. I saw the replay and it was a close call

What did they do after? Did the 3 huddle and come to a decision? Did they go to the monitor and change the call or did the replay center?
Personally, if I was an NBA ref and there was a blarge situation I do not think you involve the third ref at all. It should go to replay center and have them make the call. I hope for situations like that they have the audio off so they are not influenced by tv commentators, and have one or three replay refs make a quick review.

[TopicalTropical]

I just saw this. The thing about the FT violation amuses me. There are so many violations with FTs. Also, I know it is playoffs but the allowances for illegal screens and holding has gone way up. Especially in the Rockets-Warriors series. I think the NBA and the refs want to let things go more as best of 7 series can really grind plus all the ads, but it is not consistent with the regular season.

NBA Missed Draymond Green Lane Violation, Defends LeBron James Blocking Call | Bleacher Report | Latest News, Videos and Highlights

[RefLarry]

The lead was correct. The play should have been called a charge.

[Rich]

Originally Posted by RefLarry

The lead was correct. The play should have been called a charge.

The league said it's a block, therefore it is.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

[Jay R]

Originally Posted by RefLarry

The lead was correct. The play should have been called a charge.

Well the lead went to replay and decided to overturn his own call.