Moving Screen
Just some clarity and confirmation. It is only a "Violation" if the Offensive player makes a Illegal/Moving Screen with no physical contact and it is a "Personal Foul" if there is physical contact i.e. swings hip into defender, sticks knee out, etc.?
|
Foul if contact otherwise nothing.
|
An illegal/moving screen without contact is not an illegal/moving screen. I'm not sure what you would call it, but it's not a violation. And, of course, it's not a foul either.
|
Quote:
|
So if an offensive player moves late in front of a defensive player (to set a pick) and makes that defensive player stop or go around him without contact then there's no call? No Violation for an Illegal/Moving screen? Reason I ask I saw this in a college basketball game and called as a violation...that crew must have called it wrong then.
|
So if an offensive player moves late in front of a defensive player (to set a pick) and makes that defensive player stop or go around him without contact then there's no call? No Violation for an Illegal/Moving screen? Reason I ask I saw this in a college basketball game and called as a violation...that crew must have called it wrong then.
|
Rule 4. Definitions Section 40 Screen is where you will find your answer.
"Moving screen" is not in the NFHS rule book. Things that happen in college do not necessarily translate to NFHS. |
Crews get things wrong all the time. We just got to recognize what went wrong and learn from it.
|
Quote:
|
UMONBlue....your query makes me think of coaches/fans that want a "reach" or "over the back" called. There is no such foul.
In fact, I don't know any player that can steal a ball w/o reaching for it in some way. And there are certainly great rebounders that can simply out jump an opponent reaching higher and sometimes over an opposing rebounder. Same with a "moving screen". A player can move anywhere on the court. No foul there. Now, if the "reacher", "over the backer" or "moving screener" hold/strike, displace or contact the opponent, respectively, then we have illegal contact and thus a foul. Otherwise, happy reaching, over the backing and move screening. |
I always find it extra hilarious when a coach yells "Call the reach!"
|
Quote:
Nolan: I think you need to re-read NFHS R4-S40-A6 again before you make that statement. I don't have my NCAA Men's and Women's Rules Books in front of me but they have the same Definition as the NFHS Rules have. MTD, Sr. |
The words "moving screen" as a phrase does not show up in the case or rule books
|
Quote:
Peace |
Quote:
Seems to me that "moving screen" is a perfectly reasonable phrase to use for a foul, as a common description to why this particular illegal screen is illegal. |
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:11pm. |