The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Basketball (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/)
-   -   When has the gather occurred? (https://forum.officiating.com/basketball/102105-when-has-gather-occurred.html)

Coach Bill Fri Jan 13, 2017 11:42pm

When has the gather occurred?
 
I'd like to know when rule-wise the gather of a dribble has occurred? One of my guys does a drop-step where he takes one or two dribbles to the middle then simultaneous with picking the ball up, drops his front foot then his back and goes up strong. Is this a travel? If you rule he has gathered while his back foot is down, then it's a travel, of course. But, i don't know according to the rules when a gather has occured. I look at it similar to a Euro. Thanks!

BigCat Sat Jan 14, 2017 12:04am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Coach Bill (Post 997389)
I'd like to know when rule-wise the gather of a dribble has occurred? One of my guys does a drop-step where he takes one or two dribbles to the middle then simultaneous with picking the ball up, drops his front foot then his back and goes up strong. Is this a travel? If you rule he has gathered while his back foot is down, then it's a travel, of course. But, i don't know according to the rules when a gather has occured. I look at it similar to a Euro. Thanks!

I personally don't use the term "gather." I look at when the dribble ends and where feet are when that happens. That tells me what is pivot etc.

In your play it sounds like the dribble ends when his front foot is going back. You say he "simultaneously picks ball up and steps front foot back." When he puts two hands on ball dribble has ended. That makes his back foot pivot. You say then he moves his back foot...and goes up strong". If he picked up that back foot and put it down before shot released that's travel.

Drop step I used-player steps back with first foot while last dribble is being pushed down. It is on the floor now when he ends dribble. Other foot is then brought around (making first the pivot) and goes up strong. Maybe that is what you are describing...

In the Chris Paul u tube video of euro step he ends dribble by hand going under ball. At that moment left foot is pivot. He steps right sideways etc. then across left and then up. Left foot was down, went up and down again then releases ball. It's travel. Not called in college and not in high school if done quickly. In college the rule/case book says give dribbler benefit when figuring out when dribble ends. Thx

Raymond Sat Jan 14, 2017 07:54am

Judgement of the official

Sent from my SM-N920P using Tapatalk

bob jenkins Sat Jan 14, 2017 08:51am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Coach Bill (Post 997389)
I'd like to know when rule-wise the gather of a dribble has occurred? One of my guys does a drop-step where he takes one or two dribbles to the middle then simultaneous with picking the ball up, drops his front foot then his back and goes up strong. Is this a travel? If you rule he has gathered while his back foot is down, then it's a travel, of course. But, i don't know according to the rules when a gather has occured. I look at it similar to a Euro. Thanks!

When the dribble ends is defined in 4-Dribble (sorry, no books this morning so I can't give the exact number or quote).

But, it's when the ball comes to rest in one or both hands, or palms the ball, or touches it with both hands, or the opponent knocks it away.

Camron Rust Sat Jan 14, 2017 12:47pm

Rules-wise, there is no such thing as "gather".

Traveling is based on when the ball is held in one or both hands. As bob said "it's when the ball comes to rest in one or both hands, or palms the ball, or touches it with both hands".

Some people use the concept of gather improperly with regards to travel, essentially and incorrectly delaying start of the traveling rules to beyond when the ball is (rules-wise) caught, but when the ball is caught and secure in two hands and stably pulled into the body more like a catch in football.

Rich Sat Jan 14, 2017 01:11pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Camron Rust (Post 997405)
Rules-wise, there is no such thing as "gather".

Traveling is based on when the ball is held in one or both hands. As bob said "it's when the ball comes to rest in one or both hands, or palms the ball, or touches it with both hands".

Some people use the concept of gather improperly with regards to travel, essentially and incorrectly delaying start of the traveling rules to beyond when the ball is (rules-wise) caught, but when the ball is caught and secure in two hands and stably pulled into the body more like a catch in football.

I'd be OK if they changed the rule to reflect this, but I really think things have evolved in application cause the prevailing mindset is that it's better to miss 10 travels than to call one that isn't really there.

Coach Bill Sat Jan 14, 2017 01:53pm

Thanks everybody! By the way, I have been told by numerous officials "He had gathered to go up for the shot. Two shots." Or something similar, that includes the word gather.

BigCat Sat Jan 14, 2017 02:23pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Coach Bill (Post 997412)
Thanks everybody! By the way, I have been told by numerous officials "He had gathered to go up for the shot. Two shots." Or something similar, that includes the word gather.

Not sure where you are from but Nobody around here uses that term. Camron is right. Gather makes people think catch. That isn't the rule.

BillyMac Sat Jan 14, 2017 03:18pm

This Is What They Should Be Saying ...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Coach Bill (Post 997412)
I have been told by numerous officials "He had gathered to go up for the shot. Two shots."

The trying motion may include arm,
foot or body movements used by the player when throwing the ball at his/her basket.

Camron Rust Sun Jan 15, 2017 04:26am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rich (Post 997410)
I'd be OK if they changed the rule to reflect this, but I really think things have evolved in application cause the prevailing mindset is that it's better to miss 10 travels than to call one that isn't really there.

The travel calls I see made when not a travel usually have are not due to this.

bob jenkins Sun Jan 15, 2017 08:38am

Quote:

Originally Posted by Coach Bill (Post 997412)
Thanks everybody! By the way, I have been told by numerous officials "He had gathered to go up for the shot. Two shots." Or something similar, that includes the word gather.

Quote:

Originally Posted by BigCat (Post 997416)
Not sure where you are from but Nobody around here uses that term. Camron is right. Gather makes people think catch. That isn't the rule.

It might be an NBA term that has filtered down.

While not a NFHS rule-book term, I do think it *can* be a useful shortcut / concept.

JRutledge Sun Jan 15, 2017 08:47am

Quote:

Originally Posted by BigCat (Post 997416)
Not sure where you are from but Nobody around here uses that term. Camron is right. Gather makes people think catch. That isn't the rule.

Well it is used a lot around here. And the old funny book used to use that as the start of the habitual motion by showing a picture of the ball being "gathered" in order to show when the shooting motion had started.

Peace

just another ref Sun Jan 15, 2017 04:38pm

The use/non-use of a certain term doesn't necessarily equate to the rules. A LOT of people use the terms over the back (I don't) and on the floor. (I do, sometimes)

Mark T. DeNucci, Sr. Sun Jan 15, 2017 10:16pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by just another ref (Post 997478)
The use/non-use of a certain term doesn't necessarily equate to the rules. A LOT of people use the terms over the back (I don't) and on the floor. (I do, sometimes).




:eek: Shame on you! :p

MTD, Sr.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:35pm.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1