National Championship thread
 

I logged in this morning hoping to see some discussion of some of the calls. Seeing none, here is my contribution:

The play where Paige for UNC drives baseline, and B45 comes across the lane, approximately 5 minute mark??, I thought that was a foul. While 45 did a good job of not swinging and kept his arms "strait up" he was moving forward pretty clearly IMO.

The foul on white in the middle of the lane in the last minute I did not think was consistent with how things had been called to that point. It may have technically been a foul, but to that point there had been much more contact allowed on both ends.

Couple other calls I thought were worth discussing:

I thought the play at the 10 second mark of the first half was a foul on blue on the breakaway, but I would like to see it again.

And there was a loose ball foul called on 3white that I would like to hear people's opinions on. No idea on the time, I can't find a game log. I thought the loose ball foul on KU was an easy call, but this one not so much. I felt like that was two guys going for a loose ball.

I know this reads like I'm a UNC homer, but I promise you I'm not. These were just the first 4 calls that came to my mind.

The Marcus Paige play was not a foul, the defender jumped straight up. I rewound that play multiple times to show my son why it wasn't a foul.

On the loose ball play the UNC player knocked the Villanova down from behind.

I see no mention of the two player control fouls that should have been called in the first half against the Tar Heels but were no-called.

There were two plays in the first half where Villanova should have been called for fouls on North Carolina layups that were missed. On each play the Villanova player pushed an airborne Tarheel shooter.

Sent from my SPH-L900 using Tapatalk

I also thought there was a pushing foul by Villanova at the end of the first half.

I liked the loose ball foul called on UNC #3 Meeks midway through the second half.

TBS had the neutral/objective telecast. TNT had the UNC Team Stream. TruTV had the Villanova Team Stream. I watched it on TBS. I think that most people who watched on TNT heard a lot of complaints about the officials.

The fact that they dedicate stations to homer (read: normal team-produced telecasts) tells me that people just want to hear what they want to hear.

Violation on the opening tip? Don't often see that at this level....

If it wasn't, it sure looked weird.

I thought the same thing but wasn't able to go back and rewind.

YES!! I couldn't believe they didn't re-tip that. It barely got above their heads.

LOL, no one cares.

Really. Instead of mentioning it, people should learn from that moment.

Learn that cuz they didn't call it in the National Championship game then I shouldn't call it in my 3rd grade girls CYO games?

Mission Accomplished! :cool:

I've been to camps where clinicians went on and on and on and on and on about how important the opening jump was. I've never bought into that.

"Sorry, coach, you'll get 2 of the next 3."

If it's *really* bad, then blow it back to save the R from having to do it himself.

What's there to learn. Yes it was a violation, and it's one that is often not called at many levels. Either because the officials aren't ready, it's not expected, or no one cares.

I have called back one jump in my life and it was mostly because the jumper got off way to early, but if both jumpers leave at the same time let's start the game.

If you call a violation, you don't re-jump.

I've called it once; HS JV game years ago. I was in the second game of a three-game stretch with the same team. I saw it but froze in the first game. I was ready for it in the second game and called it. They didn't do it in the third game, but there was a fight at the end.

Edited to add: Adam beat me to this point...

There seems to be disagreement about what happened on the jump ball.

1) We have some people saying it should have been re-jumped.

2) We have others saying it is a violation.

It is a violation if the ball was touched by the player before the ball reached the highest point of the toss.

If only one player violates, I'm calling the violation and awarding the ball to the other team.

If it is just a bad toss, I'm probably just playing on unless it is egregiously bad.

Like I said, I didn't have replay so I'm not sure which happened, but if one of the players violated, we would not re-jump.

Don't you wish they violated on the jump ball?

My immediate thought was a stolen tap.

And I called it in a camp at the start of OT.

Sent from my SPH-L900 using Tapatalk

Mine too, but my second thought was, "They're never going to call that." And I was right.

Was watching an NBA final game from a long time ago on YouTube (2-man crew). They called this violation on the opening toss.

It is sometimes called at those levels and it is sometimes not called. There doesn't seem to be a strong pattern. Not sure there is much to learn form them not calling. If they had called it, they wouldn't have been the first and, since it wasn't really that close, no one would have had a problem with it.

You just have to be ready from the start. Tosses a little right,left or short I'm not calling back...if not egregious.(sp) If it is stolen it should always be called...but at times guys relax. I thought it was stolen. Refereeing's hard....have to be constantly alert. Best guys on planet make mistakes. That's how hard it is...

Wouldn't that have been before alternating possessions? I'd imagine calling the violation a lot more then...

I haven't seen an NBA game in years, really, but when did they go to AP?

Wishful thinking... :D