![]() |
Quote:
|
I'd report the timeout and let the team sort out which 5 they wanted on the floor.
I've got bigger fish to fry, to be honest. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
I'm wayyyyy late to the party here, but my question arising from this thread isn't so much about the "who's coming out" aspect. It's about the reporting aspect.
What I've learned from this is that something most officials on our board do is probably something we shouldn't be doing: Sub is at the table, team calls timeout. Official heads to the reporting area, reports the timeout, instructs timer to start the clock, says "Sub(s), you're good" and beckons, then heads to the timeout position and the rest is history. I'm getting the impression this isn't the best idea. What do you guys do? Report the timeout, ignore the sub at the table, then just see what happens when the timeout is over? Is the theory that this kid has already "reported," and since we're now in a TO, he won't need to be beckoned when play resumes? How does that approach eliminate the possibility of the OP, when the sub never enters the court following the TO and the opposing coach takes issue? Do we make the sub report before the warning horn? I can get behind this and will start doing this tonight, I just want to make sure I'm understanding it properly. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
2. You are making up your own rule for the player departing. The NFHS rule has been quoted several times in this thread. Your thinking as an official is just pathetic. |
Quote:
Do you also take the same position for intermissions? You don't care which five were in the game at the end of the previous quarter even though the NFHS recently instructed officials to pay attention to this!?!? You are setting a poor example for the officials you assign. |
Do you check the book at halftime and ensure those who were in the game at halftime return to start the second half?
I'm willing to bet scorers don't all track that. In 29 years I've never once seen a team argue that subs were improper after halftime. I have denied subs entry, but those are ones who come to the table after a warning horn OR try to reenter without sitting a tick. |
Quote:
What are you actually asking here? |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Do you actually go over and ask the scorer? As the R, I'm going to the division line and one of the Us is retrieving a ball for me. I have no problem with the rule -- I just have a problem with the feasibility of enforcing it without looking like an OOO. |
This thread has run its course and devolved into personal attacks enough times that it is now closed.
Say goodnight Gracie |
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:57am. |