rule reference

[jicecone]

Originally Posted by umpjim

So what does "if the pitcher wears a sleeve that extends below the elbow" refer to? The uniform sleeve?

Are you directing this to me or Bob?

I already stated that the interpretation was ambigous. One sentence says you can't wear anything (Medical or Compression) sleeve extented below the elbow and the other one says you can., ""provided it is not white or gray or have white/gray on it."

Somehow Bob interprets that as "The last clause ("provided it does not extend below the elbow") is meant to apply only to the previous clause ("including one that is white or gray"), which i am not saying is wrong but, I can more readily accept it , if I knew it to be true.

Again, our area enforced this as no Medical or Compression sleeve can be worn that extends below the elbow. Uniform sleeves are in conformance with their applicable rule application.

[Matt]

Oh, for the love of a comma...

"A pitcher may wear a compression or medical sleeve on one or both arms that is any color, including one that is white or gray provided it does not extend below the elbow. A doctor’s signed permission slip is not required. If the pitcher wears a sleeve that extends below the elbow, it can be worn on either arm, provided it is not white or gray or have white/gray on it. It also cannot be of a color or color combination that would be deemed distracting by the plate umpire."

Does that make more sense?

[jicecone]

Originally Posted by Matt

Oh, for the love of a comma...

"A pitcher may wear a compression or medical sleeve on one or both arms that is any color, including one that is white or gray provided it does not extend below the elbow. A doctor’s signed permission slip is not required. If the pitcher wears a sleeve that extends below the elbow, it can be worn on either arm, provided it is not white or gray or have white/gray on it. It also cannot be of a color or color combination that would be deemed distracting by the plate umpire."

Does that make more sense?

Better yet!

""A pitcher may wear a compression or medical sleeve on one or both arms that is any color. A doctor’s signed permission slip is not required. If the pitcher wears a sleeve that extends below the elbow, it can be worn on either arm, provided it is not white or gray or have white/gray on it. It also cannot be of a color or color combination that would be deemed distracting by the plate umpire."

Thanks

[umpjim]

Originally Posted by jicecone

Better yet!

""A pitcher may wear a compression or medical sleeve on one or both arms that is any color. A doctor’s signed permission slip is not required. If the pitcher wears a sleeve that extends below the elbow, it can be worn on either arm, provided it is not white or gray or have white/gray on it. It also cannot be of a color or color combination that would be deemed distracting by the plate umpire."

Thanks

Now that we have determined that the pitcher can wear a compression sleeve, what sleeve do they choose to wear? The UA with the little white logo showing. I now leave it alone since nobody complains and both sides use it. I started out asking the pitcher to rub some dirt on it or turn it inside out. Usually they would just take it off. Shows how much they need it. Usually just for show.

[jicecone]

Originally Posted by umpjim

Now that we have determined that the pitcher can wear a compression sleeve, what sleeve do they choose to wear? The UA with the little white logo showing. I now leave it alone since nobody complains and both sides use it. I started out asking the pitcher to rub some dirt on it or turn it inside out. Usually they would just take it off. Shows how much they need it. Usually just for show.

I agree, and it wasn't that big a deal when we asked to remove them because they extented below the elbow however, consistent enforcement of the rules in ALL areas is something we should always strive for.

Thanks for the clarification.

[umpjim]

Originally Posted by jicecone

Are you directing this to me or Bob?

I already stated that the interpretation was ambigous. One sentence says you can't wear anything (Medical or Compression) sleeve extented below the elbow and the other one says you can., ""provided it is not white or gray or have white/gray on it."

Somehow Bob interprets that as "The last clause ("provided it does not extend below the elbow") is meant to apply only to the previous clause ("including one that is white or gray"), which i am not saying is wrong but, I can more readily accept it , if I knew it to be true.

Again, our area enforced this as no Medical or Compression sleeve can be worn that extends below the elbow. Uniform sleeves are in conformance with their applicable rule application.

Is this 2009 interp ambiguous?

SITUATION 5: The pitcher is wearing a white compression sleeve on his pitching arm that extends below the elbow. RULING: This is not allowed. While a pitcher may wear a compression sleeve, if it is white and worn on his pitching arm, it may not extend below his elbow. A compression sleeve of any length that is neither white nor gray, or deemed to be distracting, may be worn by the pitcher on either arm. (1-4-2)

[jicecone]

Originally Posted by umpjim

Is this 2009 interp ambiguous?

SITUATION 5: The pitcher is wearing a white compression sleeve on his pitching arm that extends below the elbow. RULING: This is not allowed. While a pitcher may wear a compression sleeve, if it is white and worn on his pitching arm, it may not extend below his elbow. A compression sleeve of any length that is neither white nor gray, or deemed to be distracting, may be worn by the pitcher on either arm. (1-4-2)

Thanks.

[Dave Reed]

Originally Posted by jicecone

Are you directing this to me or Bob?

I already stated that the interpretation was ambigous. One sentence says you can't wear anything (Medical or Compression) sleeve extented below the elbow and the other one says you can., ""provided it is not white or gray or have white/gray on it."

Somehow Bob interprets that as "The last clause ("provided it does not extend below the elbow") is meant to apply only to the previous clause ("including one that is white or gray"), which i am not saying is wrong but, I can more readily accept it , if I knew it to be true.

Again, our area enforced this as no Medical or Compression sleeve can be worn that extends below the elbow. Uniform sleeves are in conformance with their applicable rule application.

I don't think the interpretation is ambiguous at all. The bolded sentence above shows where the confusion is. Contrary to what your association seems to think, the interpretation does not say "can't wear anything". Instead it tells us one thing that the pitcher may do. That doesn't tell us what the pitcher may not do. Then the interpretation goes on to tell us another thing the pitcher may do.