Oops who caught the ball?

[Manny A]

Originally Posted by JRutledge

I think this was such an unusual play that no one would have thought this is actually what happened unless they saw the tape. That is why everything stood it appears.

Well, I'm a little surprised, especially given that after F1 caught the ball, he looked over to check the runner at third, pulling the ball out of the glove in the process. You would think that one of the four umpires should have seen that, particularly the PU, who would be looking that way anyway for a pulled foot.