Common Sense and Fair Play?

[jicecone]

"but we can't discard the rules just to make it "fair"."

True statement, but it goes both ways. Where in the rules does it say that batter interference shall be decided upon, after the umpire has determined the true intent of the batters actions.

I agree with Pete if your going to make a decision based upon CSFP, make sure it is fair to both sides.