Sign not taken from the pitcher's plate (NFHS)
 

Gentleman-

How do you rule when the pitcher takes signs from the catcher when not on the pitcher's plate?

-Josh

I answered "other", so I guess I've got some 'splainin' to do.

I do not believe there is a FED rule that prohibits a pitcher from taking "signs" while off the rubber.

I do think there is one that says he "must" after engaging.

Those are two different things. If he fails the 2nd (i.e., the actual rule) I would likely kill it and instruct him to pitch properly.

JM

You forgot option #3 - "Ignore". I ignore. I don't know for sure IF he's taking signs while off the rubber, I'm not sure if whatever the catcher is doing is GIVING signs to the pitcher while he's off the rubber, and I don't see any advantage for the pitcher even if he IS taking signs off the rubber - if I see him engage and then quick pitch, I penalize the quick pitch.
This is a "looking for boogers" issue...JMO

JJ

Yep.

Peace

FED rule requires "shall" 6-1-1 pitcher to take signs from the catcher at the start of the "pitching regulation" which begins when he "intentionally contacts the pitching rubber." In the OP there is nothing against him doing that. With that said imo unless the pitchers actions results in taking longer than allotted time to deliver ball (20 seconds) or is quick pitching I am not going there.

My answer is other. As in do a search on here. This question comes up about every three months.

As long as he isn't quick pitching, leave it alone.

What signs? :confused:

Whom are you asking? :confused:

The rules prescribe no penalty. The purpose of the provision is to prevent a quick pitch, which is an illegal pitch. As long as F1 isn't in the vicinity of a quick pitch, I probably won't see it. If the O coach complains, I'll tell him to take his signs on the rubber, and then won't see it.

If he's close to a quick pitch, I'll tell F2 to get him to slow down so that he doesn't. And if he does quick pitch, I'll address that when it happens.

Frankly, I've never had a problem with this, so I don't worry much about it.

I have consistently applied the following officiating mechanic concering this topic::):confused::eek::mad::rolleyes::cool::p;):(

I answered "Other" because you didn't have a "Do Nothing" choice.

In Fed, as long as he's simulating taking signs while on the rubber, I've got nothing off the rubber.

Then again, I've still got nothing off the rubber, but a balk when he doesn't simulate them on the rubber.

I guess I should probably explain the reason for the question. In the past I have prescribed by the theory that there is no penalty listed. Specifically in our state letter to umpires the director of officials, in bold, stated "Pitcher must take his sign with pivot foot in contact with plate." Personally, I would like to know the reason for listing this but it wasn't a huge concern for me. Last night I was looking up something else in the BRD and ran across the section on this topic about taking signs off the pitcher's plate. According to the BRD, the penalty is a ball/balk.

-Josh

It's just a quick pitch prevention tool. Use it as such, and don't be the OOO.

For those non-believers: If a catcher points to first for pick-off, as F1 is climbing the hill, is that a sign? Yup.

Since no rule requires him to take a sign, what justifies demanding that he "simulate" taking one?

With an iron fist :eek:

I got nothin'. Yet. Taking signs as described is not illegal.

So ... what happened NEXT?

Yes. Of course. Still though, this does not say that he cannot take signs when not in contact with the plate. All the above advice still applies.

No rule except for the one that requires him to take a sign...

No rule requires him to take a sign. The rule means that if he takes a sign, it shall be from the pitcher's plate.

Or at any rate that's the only reasonable interpretation, since no umpire has any idea whether he's actually taking a sign. I don't imagine that you or any umpire you respect actually stops a game to make sure the pitcher is taking a sign.

NFHS Baseball Forum Thread
 

I voted other but agree with JJ that this is an "ignore" because no violation of the rules have occured.

You will not believe how many umpires think that this is a violation of the pitching rules. There was a thread on the NHFS Baseball Forum (NFHS Forum: takes the signal from the catcher) that went over 300 posts on this subject.

MTD, Sr.

Do da, do da. Lighten up and don't be OOO. Seen this call once. Post game with young partner (I did not do it).