Tough ending to game
Last at bat, visitor down 4 runs, 16 y/o state tournament birth on the line (LL seniors), 2 outs R1 on 2nd, 3-2 count, RH batter. Pitch is considerably outside. I'm PU and locked in on the pitch. If the batter made any attempt to swing, it wasn't enough for me to notice, probably because my eyes are tracking to the outside of the plate. I call ball (4) and batter tosses his bat toward the dugout down the first base line and heads to first. Several members of the defense are yelling that he swung at the ball. I'm thinking if he did, I missed it completely, but I can get help. I go to U1 (we had a 4 man crew) who bangs the batter out.
After the game U1 isn't able to explain his call to me in a way that makes any sense, so I'm thinking that maybe what happened is that the batter slightly moved his bat (outside of my field of vision) followed by a quick bat toss and U1 didn't know the difference between that sequence and an offer at the ball. This was a put together crew of guys from different local LLs and I had no idea of the skill level or rules knowledge of my partners. Could I have done anything differently, or do you just live or die with your partner's call when you ask for help. |
Quote:
Peace |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Quote:
|
Unless F2 stands up or hornets sting you in both eyes, you have to get that swing (if he indeed swings). I don't buy the tracking excuse. The swing will begin (relatively) long before your eyes track the pitch off the plate. That's your call.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
That being said, studies have shown that a very high percentage of major league players could not stop their bat once started, so why would we expect amateurs to be able to do so? Vast majority of "check swings" are swings. In my pregame I always say that if I come to you on check swing appeal to give me what you got because if I missed a strike I want it back. |
I'm not making an argument against the appeal. My question was to the post that stated that the PU has to get this call.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
So what do you propose? Should the PU have sole authority for all balls and strikes, including all swings? Should we not have a check swing appeal? |
Quote:
Peace |
Quote:
My comment referred to a situation where PU, with an unobstructed view of the batter, failed to see even an attempt at a swing (because he was tracking an outside pitch) that his partner eventually rang up. The OP intimated that it was a full swing, not a borderline check swing. That is a call that PU is expected to get without any help. You pull that stuff in college or even decent HS varsity and you will get chewed on (properly) for not getting your own calls. |
Quote:
|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:25am. |