The Official Forum

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)
-   Baseball (https://forum.officiating.com/baseball/)
-   -   Reaching base (https://forum.officiating.com/baseball/5384-reaching-base.html)

Coach&Blue Wed Jul 10, 2002 12:01pm

Can someone tell me the 9 ways to reach base? (Hint: a single, double, triple, and HR are all under the same thing - HIT)

nickdangerME Wed Jul 10, 2002 02:10pm

OK - this shows up my ignorance quite quickly. I can only come up with 8 off hand: hit, error, walk, intentional walk (unless you count that the same as a walk), HBP, catcher's interference, obstruction, dropped 3rd strike. What am I missing?

Nick

Mr. Wilson Wed Jul 10, 2002 02:52pm

I have the opposite problem of Nick...I count 10. Hit; base on balls; strikeout -- 3rd strike not caught; catcher's interference; umpire's interference; obstruction; interference by a teammate; hit by pitch; error; fielder's choice.

Rich Ives Wed Jul 10, 2002 03:35pm

Pinch Runner too.


bluezebra Thu Jul 11, 2002 01:34pm

Pinch running and fielder's choice are NOT reaching base. In PR, the player is replacing someone already on base. In an FC, the batter attains 1B because the defense opted to get another runner.

Bob

Mr. Wilson Thu Jul 11, 2002 02:03pm

If a fielder's choice isn't "reaching base," then how do you explain the guy standing on first base? I'm not trying to be a wise apple, but if it isn't "reaching base," what is it? You could just as easily make the argument that, for example, acquiring 1B because of umpire's interference is not "reaching base" because the ball was declared dead before the BR reached the bag.

I guess I interpreted the question as "What are the 9(+) ways a batter can legally end up at 1B/2B/3B/home?" Comments? Any input from Coach&Blue?

bluezebra Fri Jul 12, 2002 02:53am

Quote:

Originally posted by Mr. Wilson
If a fielder's choice isn't "reaching base," then how do you explain the guy standing on first base? I'm not trying to be a wise apple, but if it isn't "reaching base," what is it? You could just as easily make the argument that, for example, acquiring 1B because of umpire's interference is not "reaching base" because the ball was declared dead before the BR reached the bag.

I guess I interpreted the question as "What are the 9(+) ways a batter can legally end up at 1B/2B/3B/home?" Comments? Any input from Coach&Blue?

The "guy" is on 1B because the defense opted to get a leading runner. If not, they could have put "guy" out. Hit by a pitch is also a dead ball. That's legit.

Bob

spillguy Fri Jul 12, 2002 09:39pm

Quote:

Originally posted by Mr. Wilson
If a fielder's choice isn't "reaching base," then how do you explain the guy standing on first base? I'm not trying to be a wise apple, but if it isn't "reaching base," what is it? (snip)
The way I think of it FC is not "reaching base" because you are essentially "trading" one base runner for another. No "additional" base runners are on.

Coach&Blue Mon Jul 15, 2002 08:11am

I am not concerned with hits, errors, or anything like that. All I am concerned with is how a person can reach first base regardless of how they get there. 1. Hit 2. Walk 3. Hit by pitch 4. Error 5. Fielders Choice 6. Umpires Interference (not sure if it is ruled a hit or what. Don't know if its ruled differently) 7. Catchers Interference 8. Dropped 3rd Strike. I always thought there were 9 seperate ways to reach base (Guy end up standing on base or crossed home plate). I considered fan interference but don't they usually rule that a hit? Thanks for the input.

bob jenkins Mon Jul 15, 2002 10:46am

Quote:

Originally posted by Coach&Blue
I am not concerned with hits, errors, or anything like that. All I am concerned with is how a person can reach first base regardless of how they get there. 1. Hit 2. Walk 3. Hit by pitch 4. Error 5. Fielders Choice 6. Umpires Interference (not sure if it is ruled a hit or what. Don't know if its ruled differently) 7. Catchers Interference 8. Dropped 3rd Strike. I always thought there were 9 seperate ways to reach base (Guy end up standing on base or crossed home plate). I considered fan interference but don't they usually rule that a hit? Thanks for the input.
This is usually asked as a "trick" question -- the "trick" answer is "pinch-runner."



All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:05am.



Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0 RC1