What if player tells you your call was wrong?

[Hollywood]

You made the right call IMO. I always chuckle when I have a kid come up to me and admit that they didn't make the tag or something similar. It's great to see that winning isn't as important to them then doing the right thing.

In your situation, there isn't really anything else you could have done. You don't want to create a circus by calling the teams back onto the field and then everyone will be questioning your judgement in the future. Besides, from what you said, everyone else must have seen the same thing you did if no one else said anything.

JCS