Hsm

[ajjl22]

Originally Posted by jdmara

Maybe I'm just not searching for the right keywords but I can't find a recent thread on hockey style masks

I have used the traditional mask style since I began umpiring 7 years ago. I'm curious as to how many of you use a HSM. What are the advantages and disadvantages of using one? What brands/styles would everyone recommend or pass on?

TIA!

-Josh

Edit: In addition, are there any differences between the catcher and umpire HSM that you all know of?

I have and use both the HSM (Diamond) and regular mask (Wilson New View). I use the regular mask more often.

Advantages of the HSM that I've seen are:

1. A better view up and to the sides (I don't know if that helps you call pitches),

2. The weight is more evenly distributed on your head,

3. It offers more protection on the side and top of your head (if you use proper plate mechanics this should not come into play)

Advantages of a regular mask that I've seen are:
light weight,

1. easier to hold onto while dealing with line-ups,

2. spins off when hit with foul ball,

3. There is no stigma that goes with wearing a regular mask, and easier to get a hat underneath a regular mask.


Disadvantage of a HSM that I've seen are:

1. A little cumbersome when dealing with line-up cards,

2. Rattles your cage when hit with a foul ball,

3. It is hard to get a hat underneath.

4. There is some stigma that goes with wearing a HSM (it is becoming more accepted in my area.

Disadvantages of a regular mask that I've seen are:

1. The majority of the weight of the mask in on the front of your head