coaches interference
sit : R1,R2 0 outs,
pitcher steps off and throws to F3 but the throw is high. F3 chases the ball but trips over the 1stbase coach and the umpire thinks that the 1stbase coach made F3 intentionaly trip. whats the ruling ? any runner out or no advancing on the runners ? |
Quote:
Tim. |
Quote:
Depending on the circumstances of the interference, I may also consider running the assistant coach for unsportsmanlike conduct in accordance with Rule 9.01(d). |
Quote:
Smells of third world! |
rule 3.15 was the reason why i asked this question. i dont know why to call
the br out but send him back to 2ndbase. |
Quote:
ace |
Quote:
You send R2 back to 2nd, because he can't advance on the interference. You call R1 out because of the coach's interference, because a play was being made on him. You eject the coach for being an idiot, as he was the first coach you ever saw intentionally interfere with a fielder. SYJHTU. |
Quote:
|
:eek: I'm sure somewhere sometime some coach must have intentionally interfere with a fielder. In 45+ years of umpiring I have never seen it or heard of it.
I have seen stupid coaches do stupid things that caused interference, but I have never seen one do it with intent.:mad: |
Quote:
3.15 says the umpire shall impose penalties that nullify the interference. On an overthrown ball, most likely R1 and R2 advance so what would nullify this? I think it would be more reasonable to return both R1 and R2 because the ball is dead on interference and eject the coach. |
Quote:
The original play was on R1, so I'm imposing a penalty that nullifies the interference, and calling R1 out. I'm not calling offensive interference and not getting an out out of it. First I eject the coach. |
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by SanDiegoSteve
How can you say that F3 wouldn't have ran down the ball, turned and thrown to a base and got an out? Quote:
I cannot count the numerous times that R1 has been picked at 2B by F3 when there is a short fence behind the 1B bag. Dozens, for sure, hundreds, maybe. |
Quote:
If knows, then I advance all runners as liberally as possible. If the fence is long away, I give two bases to each, no discussion. If short, I give two bases to each and be ready to tell HC that his FBC is soo out of line, that if he wishes to have any further discussion, there will be two coahes ejected, not one, and a forfeit may well be in effect. |
Quote:
Holy cow Batman!!! You might want to rethink this one. 1st base coach interferes (deliberately) and you're giving the offense bases?! Hmmmm....methinks thou art incorrect. |
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:48pm. |