Topic for discussion: Handling Situations!

[GarthB]

Durham:

Such an open ended question about a subjective matter will invite subject answers. Some will be thoughtful, others will be knee jerk and betray biases of the poster.

First, the matter of poor handling of situations is extremely subjective and and related to the level of ball. How a pro umpire properly handles a situation may be deemed improper at the LL level. Appropriateness in handling situations may be in the eye of the beholder.

Second, while it may be poplular to bash umpires who handle things other than the way we think he should, it really doesn't contribute to an answer to your question. Attitude issues are a symptom, not a cause.

I believe Justme and LDUB have nailed it.

Handling situations is the most neglected area in most training programs. Most new umpires take the field with having no idea of how manage the game or handle situations.

Then, when they are surprised, they don't have a clue and are inclinded to react personally or to ignore the issue. Both directions can be perceived as arrogance, but in reality are the product of ignorance. They just don't know better.

You're to be congatulated for including this issue in your training.