Is this a journey into Smittyland?

[3appleshigh]

From the description R1 would have to be real fast to have made it to 2nd before P throws the ball. It's not when it goes out of play, but when he throws the ball. In your description you talk about where R1 was when the ball went out of play, who cares. Where was he when P threw the bal.

[LakeErieUmp]

Yeah, that was bad writing on my part. R1 took off with the pitch. By the time catcher threw back to pitcher cutting off R1 was almost at second. By the time pitcher looked it over and threw past third R1 had passed second. That's what I meant to say - R1's past second at time of throw.