The Official Forum - Bat hits ball vs. Ball hits bat

The Official Forum (https://forum.officiating.com/)

- Baseball (https://forum.officiating.com/baseball/)

- - Bat hits ball vs. Ball hits bat (https://forum.officiating.com/baseball/2643-bat-hits-ball-vs-ball-hits-bat.html)

Happened tonight in a Little League Game I was watching. I had the next game. Anyway, batter squares around to bunt and does so and the ball bounces off the ground and hits the bat again. The plate umpire call the batter out because of rule 6.05 (g) that a bat hits a ball a second time in fair territory. What would you have called here? Is there a difference that the ball hit the bat or the bat hit the ball. P.S. The ball was is in fair territory at the time of the second hit.

Your help is appreciated.

Quote:

Originally posted by abergman
Happened tonight in a Little League Game I was watching. I had the next game. Anyway, batter squares around to bunt and does so and the ball bounces off the ground and hits the bat again. The plate umpire call the batter out because of rule 6.05 (g) that a bat hits a ball a second time in fair territory. What would you have called here? Is there a difference that the ball hit the bat or the bat hit the ball. P.S. The ball was is in fair territory at the time of the second hit.

Your help is appreciated.

Adam,
Assuming the batter is still in the box, we've got a foul ball in L'Anse.
I'm going down tomorrow.
mick

[QUOTE]Originally posted by mick
[B][QUOTE]Originally posted by abergman
[B]Happened tonight in a Little League Game I was watching. I had the next game. Anyway, batter squares around to bunt and does so and the ball bounces off the ground and hits the bat again. The plate umpire call the batter out because of rule 6.05 (g) that a bat hits a ball a second time in fair territory. What would you have called here? Is there a difference that the ball hit the bat or the bat hit the ball. P.S. The ball was is in fair territory at the time of the second hit.

__________________________________________________ _______

Answer:

I believe in Fed he would be out if he intentionally contacts the ball a second time 8-4-1-d. If it was an accident it would be a foul ball.

Why we are on the topic, what would you call if the batter threw the bat at the ball making contact and advancing to first for a single. According to 3-1-m,penalty, you would eject him. But it doesn't say that you call him out. So I imagine that you would let the hit stand unless there is a rule about having to have the bat in at least one hand at the time of contact for a hit to be permitted.

Greg
__________________________________________________ _________

The worst rule ever written ?????

Quote:

Originally posted by mick
Your help is appreciated. [/B]

Adam,
Assuming the batter is still in the box, we've got a foul ball in L'Anse.
I'm going down tomorrow.
mick [/B][/QUOTE]
While I agree with your statement, Mick, I can't help but point out the Fed rule that upsets me.

Undre Fed rule only, if this batter were out of the box, and the bunt strikes his bat a 2nd time (unintentionally)in fair territory, you continue to play the ball.

Explain that one to the crowd that just saw the batter hit the ball twice!!!!! That's why it sure looks to me like the batter was still in the box.

Just my opinion,

Freix

[Edited by Bfair on Jul 13th, 2001 at 06:17 AM]

Quote:

Originally posted by Gre144
Why we are on the topic, what would you call if the batter threw the bat at the ball making contact and advancing to first for a single. According to 3-1-m,penalty, you would eject him. But it doesn't say that you call him out. So I imagine that you would let the hit stand unless there is a rule about having to have the bat in at least one hand at the time of contact for a hit to be permitted.

Try 7-3-6, second sentence.

Re: The worst rule ever written ?????

Undre Fed rule only, if this batter were out of the box, and the bunt strikes his bat a 2nd time (unintentionally)in fair territory, you continue to play the ball.

[Edited by Bfair on Jul 13th, 2001 at 06:17 AM] [/B][/QUOTE

Under what section did you get this information?

Re: Re: The worst rule ever written ?????

Quote:

Originally posted by Gre144
Undre Fed rule only, if this batter were out of the box, and the bunt strikes his bat a 2nd time (unintentionally)in fair territory, you continue to play the ball.

[Edited by Bfair on Jul 13th, 2001 at 06:17 AM] [/QUOTE

Under what section did you get this information? [/B]

8-4-1d says "intentionally contacts the ball with the bat a second time in fair or foul territory."

In addition, 8.4.1A gives a specific example.