That 4th out at 1st/run score?

[Bfair]

So, it appears the Fed feels the batter, after hitting the ball, is REQUIRED to advance to first base (just like a force).

Now, JJ, let's suppose the BR didn't advance AND wasn't played upon but merely went into the dugout or to his fielding position after seeing the third out made by R2. Would the umpire have to declare him out for not reaching and touching first base if the defense did not play on him at first base????

Your thoughts????

Freix