Ineligible Pitchers Protest--Ruling Help

[joemoore]

If it was protested I say uphold it and replay.

The problem with that is depending on when the re-schedule is the pitchers that pitched before could again if they have eligibility left.


The problem with that is that the players who played the game are 10. The team that won the game are being penalized on a technicality. That's why minors should adopt the option to disallow protests to replay games. Why penalize the players who won?

Penalize the manager. There is no problem with that.