illegal substitute

[bob jenkins]

Originally posted by DG
Now let me give you a mind bender. What if batter hits a home run in this situation, with illegal player running at 1B. What's your call, in FED? In OBR it's a walk off home run.

S1 is out (and restricted to the dugout), the home-run is nullified. See 3.1.1G

On the original play, the "next batter" is the batter *after* the advance. But, the HPB should have been ignored. Put R2 and R3 back, and let B4 bat again (with the count before the HBP).