I reread this whole thread, and I think I see why "softballfreak" was persistent. While the original question was about whether an umpire can change their mind, the response was in the context of it being questioned by a coach. The followup asked about whether a player can raise the issue. This really a seperate matter, i.e. can a player bring something to an umpire, or can only a coach or manager? I do agree that the questions could have been a little more clear.
I hope "softballfreak" will continue to read this board, as I believe much good info. and insight can be gained. I've probably learned more here than from most clinics & meetings I've been to. Players, coaches, and umpires can all better themselves by taking in the discussions that arise here. But this thread does highlight why it is good to present a well thought out question, with detailed scenarios, so that those responding can be sure of what they are responding to.
For what it is worth, IMO, most umpires are becoming more willing to listen to questions from players and others as well as just the manager/head coach, if the questions / comments are reasonable, and stated in a professional manner. This is in the spirit of getting it right, and also to try to further everyone's understanding. But the outbursts and rants are not going to be listened to.
And, yes, an umpire (we are human too) can change their mind if they are convinced they missed something. I think "under the influence" may not have been the best phrase to have used here to indicate that the umpire revised their decision, based on reviewing further info. brought to their attention.
__________________
Panda Bear
|