Quote:
Originally Posted by bob jenkins
See answers above -- but I don't have the case book handy, and the discussion has mutated enough that I'm not entirely certain to which plays you are referring
|
I believe he is not recognizing the change timing requirements for obtaining a legal guarding position.
If A1 has the ball, B1 just only get a legal position just before contact. If A2 does not have the ball, B1 must get a legal position allowing A1, if moving, 1 to 2 steps to avoid contact.
In the case he's talking about where A1 lands with one foot down and immediately collides with B1, there are two possibilities....
1. B1 obtains the position with A1 airborne but before A1 releases the ball. In that case, B1's position is judged based on the rules about guarding a player with the ball.
2. B1 obtains the position with A1 airborne but after A1 releases the ball. In that case, B1's position is judged based on the rules about guarding a player without the ball.
A position by B1 that is legal doesn't become illegal by actions of A1 (releasing the ball).