[Ump20]

Originally posted by Mike Follett

...but I still disagree, which is my right, with your opinion.
No, I don't work MLB, and yes, I work youth ball, and have done it for a long damn time. I'm a very good umpire, who also happens to project professionalism on the field, albeit for those players 18 and under. You use the term "youth ball" like there's something less important about calling at that level, than whatever level you happen to work for. Here's a newsflash for you pal; there's a lot more of us, than there are of you. Just because I happen to give my time to the youth of my community, who that game means more to than anyone, doesn't mean I'm any less of a pro at what I do, than you.
Not once have I heard anyone with any common sense, say, "Man, that guy behind the plate sucks because he doesn't have his hands hanging out in front of him like an ape".
If that's one of the keys that you use to judge a fellow umpire, it must suck to be you.

Mike is certainly free to disagree about whether or not it is the right technique or looks good to have your hands behind your back when you work the plate. I had a partner this past weekend in the second game of a doubleheader with this habit. I noticed it immediately. He also seemed to have some issues with dugouts questioning his zone. I think the point Rich made is that umpires who want to "move up" the ranks should not assume this position when calling balls and strikes. If you are comfortable doing whatever level of ball you are doing and this stance works for you than stay with it. I umpire "youth ball" and take it quite seriously as well. Jim / NYC