Quote:
Originally Posted by Camron Rust
Can't debate the point with facts so attack the opponent? If your way was correct, surely you could come up with something better than that to support your point. Sure, we must make judgement, but those judgement MUST be based on a RULE.
Here are the RULES I go by:
You're saying that if a player passes after starting a shooting motion and being fouled, it was not a shot to start with. Back up that claim with a rule or case play. Show me ANYTHING close to supporting what you're proposing. ANYTHING?
I'm not saying it is always a shot when a player passes, but the FACT is that what follows the foul is not part of the definition of a try.
|
[QUOTE=Camron Rust;965451]
Quote:
Originally Posted by BigCat
So, you're saying you have to read the player's mind if the foul prevents the release? It could have been a pass???
|
I, we, have to make a judgment. did it prevent or not. what i see you saying is if the m ovemtns look like a shot it is a shot and no judgment... lets move to something else...thx