|
I appreciate all that has been written in this thread about when and how (and when not) to allow an "appeal" of a judgement call... It also seems obvious that there are no clear cut absolutes on the topic.
You have observed correctly.
With regard to my original scenario... I saw everything I was going to see before I made my call. I could have waited for three days to make the out call and I would still NOT have seen the pulled foot by F3 from the C position.
That being the case, you probably did the right thing. All some of us are suggesting is that when that happens, when you feel you absolutely need to get help, go ahead, but don't stop there. Afterwards, spend the time to analyze why you didn't see what you needed to see and try to determine if there was something you could have done, something you can do in the future, to see what you need to see to not need help.
[Edited by GarthB on Jul 18th, 2003 at 10:27 AM]
__________________
GB
|