|
Not necessarily
I appreciate all that has been written in this thread about when and how (and when not) to allow an "appeal" of a judgement call. I had no idea my scenario would generate such a debate. I think the dead horse has been thoroughly beaten by now. It also seems obvious that there are no clear cut absolutes on the topic.
With regard to my original scenario... I saw everything I was going to see before I made my call. I could have waited for three days to make the out call and I would still NOT have seen the pulled foot by F3 from the C position.
Since there is no apparent accepted practice for handling this type of situation, it seems that each individual must let his conscience be his guide in handling any given scenario. Thanks for your thoughts.
|