Quote:
Originally Posted by mutantducky
I and someone hits the player's body or arms when they are stretched up for the layup.
|
95% of the time when the player is still "stretched up" the player is still in the air (or maybe I'm not picturing what you are describing correctly).
I think part of the issue in this is the timing -- the first nano-second of contact is probably not yet a foul. But at some time, the contact causes a disadvantage and becomes a foul.
You can give the benefit of the doubt to the shooter when you're not sure whether the first contact happened before or after the player returned to the floor. But, in (at least most of) your descriptions, you have not had any doubt that the player was on the floor -- that should NOT be a shooting foul.