Quote:
Originally Posted by APG
I guess I'm a little confused about what you're trying to convey here.  If we have this attitude about discussing plays, we might as well shut down this forum or any discussion group.
Nothing wrong with discussing plays and even saying an official missed a play (which may have happened with the facemask play in question). |
The intent is to suggest, as I presume most officials clearly understand, is that is that an officials judgment call is based on what is ACTUALLY seen, rather than what might be suspected, possible or even apparent.
An official judging he didn't see a hand grasping a facemask, or helmet openting, doesn't mean it didn't happen, only that the official didn't see it happen. As a n official we don't have the luxury of presuming. Absent any constructive suggestion (rule knowledge, mechanics and positioning advice or some material instruction that might benefit future calls) there doesn't seem to any real value in complaining about something someome else did, or didn't, actually see (without benefit of detailed review and assessment)