[MD Longhorn]

Originally Posted by bainsey

For the first time, our little co-ed, slow-pitch rec league had some confusion about how men and women alternately. Our league rule is that there is a maximum of six men in the field (ten total), and men and women must bat alternately until one gender is exhausted. (We also allow two EHs.) I question whether I wrote that rule correctly.

Tonight, Team A had four women; Team B had five. Because of the way I wrote the rule, the A captain insisted that B bat all five women in their line-up, even though they used four in the field. One could argue that one woman would always be an EH, and you must bat up to six women that show up. The counterargument is that, "we could just send one woman home" to keep batting four.

What's the ASA rule about this? Is there any maximum to the amount of women in the lineup, when you only require four in the field? (You can put more women in the field, by our rule.) I appreciate any thoughts.

Local rules that are invented by leagues often (nearly always) neglect to cover some situation. Sounds like this one did too.