Quote:
Originally Posted by Andy
Mike...I simply asked a queston based on the description of the play. I didn't dismiss the call...just provided something else to consider.
|
This is to what I am referring:
If the movement of the catcher caused the collision, I would not apply this rule and play on.
8.7.Q makes no mention of intent (you know that, just sayin') nor what causes to collision though there is the need for some level of consideration.
It isn't as if the catcher went charging up the line at the runner, but stepped into a defensive position of the plate that was in the runner's path. A defender with the ball is allowed, actually expected to defend the base.
I'm simply stating that the catcher is the one who moved toward the runner that may or may not have caused the collision is not cause to not make the call.