Quote:
Originally Posted by youngump
As to the baseball stuff: yes it's a tag. You're the first person discussing it I've heard suggest that replay isn't conclusive.
|
Unless you have a three-dimensional view, you don't know it is a tag for sure, even from the replay. Sure, it looked like it could be, but neither you, me, the umpire or camera really knows for sure.
I find it hard to believe you have never seen a player reach out and it looked like a tag from your angle, but it was still questioned. Happens more often than you might think, but the umpire must make a judgment call based on the information available.
Quote:
|
Most reviews are whether tags were made or not or if they were in time so I'm not sure where you're going with that.
|
Going with what, the fact that I'm not a fan of a review of a judgment call? And, to be real, to me it seems the baseball review seems to make the call, not provide more information as done in other sports