Quote:
Originally Posted by AtlUmpSteve
Rita, I think we on this board have had that "the defense erred" discussion before. Here's the process:
1) Offense failed to hit strike three; be it swinging or called.
2) Defense failed to catch strike three. Defense needs to make a play to complete the out. Offense catches a break here.
How/why does the offense now get consideration for a free pass if batter-runner's actions keep the defense from completing the out? Sure, defense didn't catch it, but offense didn't hit it.
|
There ought to be some room for doubt for the batter if it lands at her feet.
But if intent isn't to matter, so be it. I'll call it that way. But doesn't mean I have to like it.
Rita