Quote:
Originally Posted by Pantherdreams
Feet down - check
Facing player with the ball - Check
Inside her cylinder/vertical plane - Check
No idea what the defender did wrong.
Think the idea that her torso is moving forward is moot unless she's somehow got it moving beyond her toes and outside her cylinder.
Technically everytime someone breathes or tenses their abs there is going to be outward/forward movement with their torso. Saying that that is forward movement would be ridiculous. I'm putting any movement of the torso as they brace/straighten/settle in the same category unless it puts them outside their allowed space. I don't feel that is the case here.
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by BadNewsRef
I would not want to try to justify a block to a supervisor based on this reasoning.
|
Here is the one part of the rule you're both leaving out....
Quote:
|
The guard may move laterally or obliquely to maintain position, provided it is not toward the opponent when contact occurs
|
This requirement is absolute. It is not qualified by any point of reference relative to the feet or a position. If the guard is moving forward, even just a little, it is not LGP. Period.
This player isn't "breathing" to cause the forward movement or straightening up, it is the primary act of trying to get a position that isn't yet complete.
For that matter, if the defender's torso is still moving forward, the defender didn't even get there first, which is also a basic requirement for guarding. That much is pretty basic.
You can argue that the player in any specific play might not have been moving forward but once you allow that she was (as JetMetFan did above), you can't have anything but a block.