Quote:
Originally Posted by jeremy341a
I would most definetly give her a T even if there wasn't retaliation. I am surprised to hear others wouldn't. We don't give warnings for traveling. Why would we for unsporting acts?
As for the penalties. Initially you sai you wouldn't give her a T if there wasn't a punch. Yet later she gets a T in the scenario in which there wasn't a punch. Seems to me either her actions are T worthy or not.
She caused the fight. If she doesn't shove green no punches get thrown. Therefore my view is both are dq'ed.
|
Like it or not, and no matter how many times we try to say a T is no different than any other call, it is different. The fact is, I think this is borderline by itself.
In all honesty, by itself, I couldn't tell you whether I'd warn first on this or not. It depends on how the game had gone overall to that point.
But, on borderline stuff, warnings are generally expected here, so I oblige.
But if I was on this game, she'd be done.