Quote:
Originally Posted by bigjohn
I am just saying that according to the rules as written, it should have been blown dead!
That is my intent.
|
So ... the 2nd one.
No offense, but it is not as easy as reading the book and stepping on the field. It takes practice, study, discussion to understand the little things - like "how long must the ball be at rest to blow it dead" in situations like this one. And THIS play is not at all what was meant by the rule you keep quoting. This rule is so that in those odd cases (picture a punt return) that the ball comes to rest without anyone around who might touch it and kill the play - we can kill the play. It is not meant to cover loose balls where players who might potentially advance that ball are standing near it.
If your intent is to actually understand the rules, please listen to those who spend time, effort, and money to learn how to interpret them.
If your intent is to simply stir things up, it grows very tiresome.