Quote:
Quote:
Originally Posted by RPatrino
I feel that all umpires on the field are equally responsible for trying to avoid misapplications of rules and protests.
|
|
Agreed if the "other" umpires are 150% certain that a rule was misapplied.
I give benefit of doubt to my partner making the call. Perhaps he saw something different then me.
Let's takes umpjm's simple example of a pitched ball going out of play and the PU awards 2 bases.
I step in and say no he only gets one base. We then converse and my partner says "Pete F2 kicked the ball into DBT while chasing the errant pitch which is the reason I awarded 2 bases".
Now we as a group look like s**t and give the appearance we do not know what the h**l we are doing. In addition your partner will give you that look like "stay out of my business unless I ask for your help" Our credibility will be questioned the remainder of the game.
Let the manager do his job if he doesn't like or agree with a rule interp.
In a nusthell, unless it's a "no brainer" the other umpires should not say or do anything unless the manager lodges a protest or the umpire who made the call requests assistance.
Pete Booth