Quote:
Originally Posted by Dakota
So, by that logic, the last sentence of ASA Rule 8-7-P-NOTE means nothing at all.
We cannot treat the ASA Rule Book as inerrant holy writ.
Assigning high precision on the use of "the" in a rule book that is rampant with the use of "their" and similar words as if they were singular is almost a breach of logic in and of itself.
In the OP, fan interference prevents the defense from making the catch.
The literal application you advocate, whereby there can only be one offended team, causes an even greater damage, only this time the damage is inflicted by the umpire, (preventing the offense from scoring).
This hardly seems like this should be the intent of the rule.
|
Not sure what 8-7.P NOTE has to do with this topic, but, to be clear, I am only relating to the NCAA application of their rule on this play (OP). ASA clearly tells us to place all runners after the dead ball and out.