Play 1 would never have happened had the PU been properly maintaining the lineup sheet. He/she would have seen where the CR was used before and not allowed their illegal use.
In Play 2, the runner should be awarded home. Unlikely that she wouldn't get back around to the 1st base side of 2nd before the ball went out of play (maybe she was almost to 3rd by the time of the throw), but if that's the case, her retag would be disallowed.
|