[QUOTE]
Quote:
Originally Posted by Manny A
Are you suggesting that the umpires on the field aren't neutral?
The MLB system in place is fine.
|
Exactly What is the MLB System?
Apparently it is not clearly defined with respect to type of video equipment to be used.
Why use a neutral site (reference Tee's post)?
makes sense and is the most cost effective. The alternative would be to have each stadium equipped with similar video equipment plus have a replay booth manned by former MLB umpires which would cost money. Yeah I know baseball is big business but how many questionable HR's do you get a year.
There is already (again refer to Tee's post) a neutral site in NY with all camera angles you need. The people in this neutral site are not making calls or rulings but simply giving the umpires all angles needed to make the final call.
Bottom Line: MLB (where's Bud been but that's another topic altogether) needs to clearly define Replay with respect to video equipment.
Pete Booth