|
What organization (NCAA/USAV/NFHS)
Judging by the time of posting, I'm going to assume USAV until we know otherwise.
You won't find the answer to this specific question since it's too specific. You'll have to interpret and apply the rule in your best judgement (the glories of the job, right?)The best way to determine whether or not this is a fault is by taking into account what IS deemed a fault when referencing net violations:
Was the top of the net contacted while in the action of playing the ball?
Since I doubt this is what happened from the sound of what you've mentioned, we can rule this out.
Was the team in question given an advantage while playing the ball, in action of playing the ball, while contacting the net?
The key to this is while playing the ball. If the ball wasn't being played during the time of the incident, then no net fault has occurred.
Was there interference with the opponent while the net contact was being made?
This one is tricky, and may be the more applicable of the above infractions. Interference is not only tricky to explain to coaches, but is tricky to judge and decide when, when not to whistle. Did the net contact hinder the opponents from making a play on the ball (distraction or physically unable to play the ball)? Was there illegal contact between the opposing teams while the net was being contacted?
If you've answered no to the above questions, then no fault has occurred. Unfortunately, (and maybe fortunately in some cases), the rule book doesn't cover every single possible fault with each and every rule. It only joins the casebook collection should it happen frequently or with potentially more frequents. With that, you have to use the rule book as a guide to form decisions on situations that aren't so clear cut and direct.
Curious as to who your source was that made the claim? Parent, player, coach, fellow official?
Hope this helps though!
|