Quote:
Originally posted by kellerumps
Presently, there is no such animal as an NCAA softball umpire. They are softball umpires who work NCAA games.
Not entirely correct. To work in the Major NCAA conferences, you must be evaluated and hired. There is more and more pressure being placed on us to work only NCAA games...be it D1, D2, or D3. It doesn't matter. Basketball and Baseball officals face the same problems. With the travel commitments we must make, its not really worth it to work other "Spring" ball.
No one is specifically trained as a NCAA umpire, but there are umpires trained in the NCAA rules and prescribed mechanics. So far, from what I've witnessed on the field, many of those prescribed mechanics can vary by region, but they all achieve the same purpose and the differences would most likely only be noticed by veterans.
Right now that is true but it is changing very very quickly. Further, that can be said about any other college official.
There is a huge training commitment that a serious umpire must make. Next year for the first time ever the NCAA is having regional rules/mechanics meetings next spring just like basketball/baseball officials have the last several years. Umpires that work in the Major D1 conferences will be required to attend these meetings. Further, we are being evaluated on a more consistent basis and those that are not following the NCAA way of doing things face the prospect of being dropped.
Like I stated, College Softball is becoming big buisiness. That not only means bigger paychecks  but also alot more stress and expectations 
Once again I will say that we have been extremely lucky. We were in the right place at the right time and met the right person that liked what he/she saw and gave us a chance. Further, we live in a very umpire rich area and have been successful in surrounding ourselves with top level ASA, ISF, and NCAA umpires and friends.
Time for bed.
|
Please understand, I was in no way attempting to degrade those who work college ball.
I'm well aware that the NCAA is making a move toward gathering control of their softball umpires, though I do not agree with the "collegiate ball only" trend of thought.
The NCAA has no standard system(yet) upon which to rate the umpires, that is done by the associations to which the umpire belongs and probably some conferences have advisors who do the same. And if the associations want to still be included in the long haul, they will be quite strict and well-heeled in their effort to put the best umpires on the field. There is also no standard for obtaining umpires for ball games. Some still contract locally, some conferences contract for the member schools and so on.
However, you can rest assured that the NCAA will have their claws into this within the next couple of years.
My only problem with it is that many schools still play the afternoon games on weekdays. That means there are still some pretty decent umpires omitted from the groups as they have real jobs which to not permit them to travel or work during certain times of the day.
