Quote:
Originally Posted by Toren
Situation 10 and Peter Webb and Art Hyland (through John Adams) all disagree with your interpretation. If you want to shoot me an email address, through a private link, I will shoot you the email I received from those gentlemen.
|
I believe you. That doesn't make them right. All it takes is a basic reading of the rule to see that.
My take on the rule is FAR from unique and that was the way it was called for decades before someone pulled situation 10 out of thin air.
The situation just flat out contradicts the rule. It wouldn't be the first time someone in high places made a ruling contrary to the actual rules. Usually, they either admit their error or change the rule to make themselves correct.
If they wanted to change the rule to mean that, they should rewrite the rule, not write a situation that disagrees with the rule.