[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by rfp

I guess which violation does matter after all in my sitch!

So, yes, A-1 steps on the line and violates. The disconcertion is what was throwing me, since usually if the balls goes in you would ignore the disconcertion. But since A-1 violated you can't count the basket. So you have a simultaneous violation that's treated differently than it usually is, as BillyMac points out. So, it's an unusual case.

Thanks!

It's not a simultaneous violation -- that's penalty 3.

You had penalty 4.