One of the problems with local rules and the unforeseen effects is that local staffs and committees are not rules experts, even if they are softball/baseball experts. Also, the rule makers usually go by their preference for restrictions, not what's best or most neutral. If only they checked with nationals or other leagues to see why a given rule would or would not work. And possibly get suggested wording that does work. They might even ask umpires for the eventual procedural questions. Do any geos get in the way? For the lower levels, I think runs per inning works best, but I'm sure everyone has their own preference.
Also, I would not umpire after a game is possibly final, because of the liability and bad management precedent.
|