Quote:
Originally Posted by MD Longhorn
Mike, that play doesn't really differentiate well - as the runners are getting 2 bases from TOP, and also 2 bases from TOK (time of kick?  ). Since neither runner had advanced a base, the bases at TOP and TOK are the same.
Incidentally, 8-5G refers to live overthrown balls and blocked balls... where is the rule that tells us to treat an unintentionally kicked ball as a thrown ball? |
Just in the way of comparison with other rule sets, and this example has some holes in it also....
If the play as described in the OP occurred in an NCAA game, the ruling would fall under
9.9 Fair Batted Blocked Ball.
The rule contains no mention of an intentional/unintentional act of the part of the fielder, it only says "when it deflects," and then the umpires would essentially have to combine two sections of the rule to apply the correct ruling.
9.9 Fair Batted Blocked Ball
A fair batted ball becomes blocked:
9.9.3 When it bounces over, wedges under, or passes through a fence or any designated boundary on the field........
9.9.4 When it
deflects off of a defensive player and crosses into dead ball territory.......
EFFECT-(9.9.2 to 9.9.4)-The ball is dead. The batter is awarded second base and credited with a two-base hit (double). Each runner is awarded two bases from the base legally occupied at the
time of the pitch.