Quote:
Originally Posted by IRISHMAFIA
Speaking ASA
To start, dead ball should be called when the ball enters DBT, not when a runner finishes running the bases. 
However, the runner can touch whatever base they choose. What are you going to do, block the base path? Once the runner touches/passes an awarded base, s/he cannot return to touch a base missed or left too soon. While the rule notes this as an illegal act, you cannot rule the runner out for simply returning to touch a base when not permitted.
The defense must still make the proper appeal and, but rule, that must be for the runner leaving the base too soon or missing it. |
Right, the award is given after allowing the runner to complete their base running responsibilities. The dead ball is immediately after the ball enters DBT.
I'm applying the same logic to an unreported sub or illegal substitution. Just because it is illegal doesn't mean we prevent it. We allow it knowing that they are violating the rule and rule accordingly when called upon to do so.