Quote:
Originally Posted by mbcrowder
I don't buy it, but let me ask you this.
Say BR simply refuses to go to 2nd, or leaves the field of play after advancing to 1st. Would we treat the out at 2nd as a force? Of course not.
|
No, because it is a dead ball.
Quote:
More food for thought. A ground rule double is also a 2-base award. A runner from 2nd would similarly be "forced" to vacate 2nd base. However, if you ruled such a player missing 3rd base on his way home to be a "force out", you'd be laughed out of the locker room. So why is THIS 2-base award different from THAT 2-base award?
Answer ... it's not.
|
Yeah, it is because, as noted, all runners are awarded bases on a GRD or any ball which goes out of play. Only the batter is awarded base(s) on a walk.
Look, no one is arguing this isn't strange or even arguable, but as the rules read, it is what it is