Quote:
Originally posted by IRISHMAFIA
... snip ... Yes, you should make the call as soon as you see anything to which the runner reacts by slowing down, checking-up or alters their base path to avoid a defender without or not about to receive the ball. If they reach the base to which you believe they were entitled, you drop the call.
You make the call because you cannot foresee the future and making it in a timely fashion eliminates any question as to the integrity of the call.
|
I agree with all that you said. I was trying to make the point that it is not really obstruction if none of the effects you mentioned (my bolding) occur. I was further suggesting not anticipating the call because you don't know (1) whether the runner will react or (2) if their slide or dive will take them to an unblocked part of the base or (3) if the fielder will move (e.g., while trying to catch the ball).
Yes, there is a question about selling the call if you wait until afterward to call it, but there is an equal question about selling the call if you seem to make your decision before the play.