[Andy]

I have not read the articles in question, but I think that Mike made a point that is probably closer to what the author is intending.

I read "volunteer umpire" as the person who steps out of the stands to call the game so the kids can play. There are some leagues out there that choose to cut costs by using that type of umpiring system. I would tend to agree that a paid umpire, even at 50%, would probably be better.

Striker - you and your organization are to be commended for volunteering to umpire for your community and working to better yourselves as umpires. I would not lump you and your group into "volunteer umpires" as I described above.

Mike's second point is also well taken. While money is not my primary motivation for umpiring and I have done several volunteer assignments, the few extra bucks is nice to have.